Showing posts with label nfl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nfl. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Power Rankings Are Inevitably Useless


All stats are based upon ESPN NBA, NFL, and NHL Power Rankings.

Last week, the Colts were the best team in the NFL. This week, the Saints are the best team in the NFL. Remember when the Giants were #1? The Vikings and Broncos sit at #3 and #4, yet the Ravens, who almost beat the Vikings and demolished the Broncos, are #10. In the beginning of the NBA season, the Denver sits 4th in the Power Rankings as an undefeated team, yet undefeated #10 Phoenix and #11 Miami sit behind 2-2 #9 Portland. Even the NHL can't get it right with the Blue Jackets at #24 with a record of 7-5-1 behind the Islanders at #20 despite a 4-4-5 record.

Why? Why use or even follow power rankings? In the end, they never really tell you where a team is. It's all on paper. How are the Patriots seated at #5 after derailing two 0-and-whatever teams, one of whom have a depleted secondary? During the season, they barely beat the Bills (and I mean, barely) and were shut down by the Jets and Broncos. If the Patriots were 4-3 (in that game against the Bills) instead of 5-2, would they be as low as the other 4-3 teams? And what about the Ravens? They just competed against #3 and #4 of the Power Rankings and ended up defeating #4 convincingly and coming a FG short of beating #3, so why are they at #10? Also, when was the last time a #1 team went all the way and won?

How can an undefeated team in the NBA thus far not be in the Top Ten of the Power Rankings? If the argument is that the undefeated teams have beaten up on weak teams, the Cavs haven't beat anyone of note for them to be at #7 (Minnesota and Charlotte) and were beaten by #1 Boston and #20 Detroit. Oh, but we base them on what they "potentially" are on paper. The Thunder are at #19 with a 2-1 record, yet there are teams with losing records that haven't looked as good as they are above them? If anyone caught the L.A./OKC game last night, it's obvious that the Thunder are a better team than they're being given credit for. Denver at #4? They're the second sharpest looking team in the NBA right now (next to Boston, who is rightfully at one).

Power rankings are absolutely useless. Regardless of how you try to rank teams, they'll never tell you how good or bad a team truly is because everything in sports is based on match-ups and how you play on that day. It's the reason why a #8 Golden State can topple the NBA's best record team Dallas Mavericks in 2007. It's why 18-0 can result in 18-1. It's how both #1 seeds in the NHL playoffs lose in either the opening or 2nd round of the Playoffs. It's why the BCS is such a mess (because, essentially, the BCS is just Power Rankings). If at the end of the day, we're judging teams based on what they win/accomplish at the end of the season, why do we bother with Power Rankings and worry about where a team is in term of this system?

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

The Curious Case of the Buccaneers: The Guide To Going 0-16



With the Rams snapping their 17-game losing streak against the former 0-16 Lions and Vince Young picking up a victory for the Titans, the Bucs are the only team still ready to continue their streak to perfection. No, not imperfection. That insists that there is a flaw in their plans and the only flaw in this situation is a win. The '07 Dolphins reached imperfection when they decided they didn't want to try to lose a game against the Ravens and slack off in the quest to perfection. Much like the 07' Patriots will be remembered as "Eighteen and ONE" and choke artists in their quest perfection, the Dolphins are remembered are "ONE and Fifteen".

However, there is a method to all of the madness on the road to 0-16 and I've got the formula that the Buccaneers must follow in order to follow the Lions of last year and take their place in history:


Have No Clue Who Your Quarterback Is

This is the first step to the dream. Looking back at the Detroit Lions and the Miami Dolphins (as they were on their quest), they both had early severe injuries to their starters (Jon Kitna and Trent Green) which then sent them into a frenzy in trying to figure out who is their quarterback. Neither of their backups were truly capable of being NFL starters, so they just tried different quarterbacks throughout the season. The Dolphins went through first-round pick John Beck and Cleo Lemon. However, the Lions not only went through Dan Orvlosky and Drew Stanton, they also went out, became desperate, and signed Daunte Culpepper, who came out of retirement to play. This is why the Rams were able to win on Sunday and why they don't fit the equation: they know that Marc Bulger is their quarterback and that he is their answer.

The Bucs are already ahead of the game because they didn't know who their quarterback was from Week One. No injuries to report, yet they're ready to start their third quarterback already, first-round pick Josh Freeman, after going through journey Byron Leftwich and Josh Johnson. They've gotten desperate enough to even let wide receiver Michael Clayton throw a pass. I suppose that is more productive than letting them play receiver since he drops so many passes. Hell, it goes beyond just their quarterback. They can't even settle on a kicker. They've started with Mike Nugent, who was ineffective. They then got rid of him and turned to Shane Andrus. Now, they've released him and turned to Connor Barth. I can't wait to see them start having their wide receivers start trying out for kicking duties.


Must Have One Player Who Plays At A Level Above Everyone Else

For the Dolphins, during their 0-13 run, it was Ronnie Brown. Ronnie Brown was having a phenomenal season and no one else on that team (except perhaps Chris Chambers, who the Dolphins then traded that season) was playing at the level he was. Unfortunately, the team's leading rushing for the season (and, at the time, leading receiver) was knocked out for the season by Week 7. For the Lions, it was Calvin Johnson. He was in the Top 5 of quite a number of major receiving statistics and earned the name Megatron. No one else had what he had. Had he been on any other team than the 0-16 Lions, he would have been a Pro-Bowler. But going 0-16 is not an individual effort. It is a team effort and that is why they got there together.

Now, if the Rams hadn't blown it against the Lions last week, the answer would easily be Steven Jackson for them. I can't even name any of their receivers (remember back in the day when Rams' receivers were feared?) or 75% of their roster if I were asked. But, we do have the Bucs to work with and their player has to Aqib Talib, their phenomenal cornerback. In the one game that they could have won this year, he tried to ruin the perfect season by picking off Redskins' QB Jason Campbell three times and put the Bucs in a position to win. When the Patriots were kicking them into the dirt, Talib put his foot down and went out and made plays against the Pats. However, the rest of the team in the Redskins' game got their act together and did nothing in the Second Half as Nugent missed field goals, the offense committed turnovers, and even Aqib Talib got on the same page and let Santana Moss blow right by him for the TD that sealed the game.


Must Trade A Huge Name During The Season

This is what cements it. This is how you know you're on the track to a 0-16 season. When the Dolphins were rolling down that path, they traded their rising receiver Chris Chambers to the Chargers before their departure to England for their game against the Giants. For the Lions, it was Roy Williams who was traded to Dallas.

The Buccaneers took a different route and traded former first-round pick and defensive end Gaines Adams to the Bears for their 2010 second-round pick. Of course, the trade has not solved any of their problems and their woes continues. Looking at the rest of their schedule, there doesn't seem like there is a game they might win. Their best chances come in consecutive weeks (@ Carolina, vs. Jets, @ Seattle), but according to this formula, they don't have a chance.


- R. Mitchel